The Amityville house for sale listings in the area continue to generate intense curiosity among buyers and paranormal enthusiasts. Many visitors ask whether any active properties genuinely carry the historic address tied to the infamous 1974 events.
Below you will find a quick scan of key property details, a deep dive into buying considerations, and answers to pressing questions that often appear in search queries around this address.
| Property ID | Address | Year Built | Asking Price | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NY-11201-045 | 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville, NY | 1920s | $1,350,000 | Active |
| NY-11201-078 | 14 Manor Road, Amityville, NY | 1950s | $980,000 | Pending |
| NY-11201-112 | 23 Chapel Lane, Amityville, NY | 1890s | $1,650,000 | Active |
| NY-11201-130 | 5 Harborview Drive, Amityville, NY | 1970s | $1,125,000 | Withdrawn |
Historic Property Background
Houses tied to the Amityville story are often older wood-frame structures set on sizable lots that reflect early twentieth century construction. These homes typically feature detailed trim, original hardwood floors, and period-appropriate fixtures that preservationists appreciate. Many buyers are drawn not only by location but by the chance to own a property with documented paranormal reputation and documented history.
Current Market Inventory
Active listings for properties directly linked to the famous address are rare, but surrounding neighborhoods in Amityville and nearby hamlets do show comparable homes. Working with a local broker who understands short sales, estate auctions, and probate transfers increases your odds of catching a newly listed house with authentic lineage. Checking multiple listing services weekly helps you act quickly when a relevant property surfaces.
Buying Considerations and Inspections
When evaluating any house marketed with an Amityville connection, treat the narrative as one factor among many, not the primary driver of value. Structural inspections are essential, especially for older homes that may have outdated wiring, plumbing, or foundation issues. Verify permits, check flood zone status, and review title records to ensure the seller has clear rights to transfer the property.
Neighborhood Safety and Schools
Research crime statistics, walkability scores, and nearby amenities to confirm the area aligns with your lifestyle needs. School district ratings influence resale value significantly, even if you do not have children, because strong schools tend to stabilize long term prices.
Next Steps for Interested Buyers
- Contact a reputable local broker familiar with historic districts and short sale inventory.
- Set up alerts for new listings in the 11201 zip code to act quickly when relevant homes appear.
- Schedule independent inspections focused on structural integrity, environmental risks, and code compliance.
- Verify financing options early and confirm lender comfort with the property’s title and condition.
- Document all representations in writing and review disclosures carefully before closing.
FAQ
Reader questions
Is the house at 112 Ocean Avenue actually on the market right now?
No verified active listing exists for the exact 112 Ocean Avenue address, though properties nearby occasionally appear and are marketed with thematic naming. Real estate platforms may show expired or relisted status, so confirm through a licensed broker before making an offer.
Do banks finance homes with a known haunted reputation?
Standard mortgage underwriting does not typically bar financing solely because of a property’s history, but appraisal challenges can arise if comparable sales are limited. Buyers should secure pre-approval and discuss any concerns with their loan officer early in the process.
How does the resale value compare to similar homes without the story?
Properties with a notorious background sometimes linger on market longer and sell below neighboring comparables, yet niche collectors and entertainment ventures occasionally pay premiums. Long term value depends far more on structural quality, location, and neighborhood trends than on anecdotes.
Are there legal disclosure requirements for haunted stories in New York?
New York law does not require sellers to disclose paranormal claims, but material facts affecting safety or marketability must be revealed. Consult a real estate attorney if you plan to include specific representations about the property’s past in your purchase agreement.